Con Fire Lead Chaplain and Antioch priest Father Robert Rien (left), Councilwoman Jovita Mendoza (right) and the disputed photo from her campaign mailer. Sources: Herald file photo, Brian Oftedal and Mendoza campaign Facebook account posted on Jan. 18, 2024.
“She had absolutely nothing to do with the merger… I know who did and didn’t work on it…” Con Fire Chaplain Fr. Robert Rien
Calls for Jovita Mendoza’s censure by city council
Also questioned about using official City email for campaign, challenged by opponent for not signing Code of Conduct but does not respond
UPDATE: Mendoza responds via video doubles down with no apology for use of photo
By Allen D. Payton
A mailer was sent out by Brentwood District 1 City Councilwoman Jovita Mendoza in support of her re-election campaign, in District 3, that included a photo of herself and Con Fire Lead Chaplain Fr. Robert Rein, a Catholic priest and Pastor of St. Ignatius Church in Antioch, which he says she didn’t have permission to use. He sent a letter to the editor last week sharing that fact, saying he hasn’t endorsed the councilwoman and that he’s asked Mendoza to “revoke the flyer and clarify that she used my photograph with her fraudulently.” Yet, as of last Friday, Oct.19 she had not responded to his email sent the week before.
“No, I haven’t received any phone call or email from her, as of today,” Rien said. “I thought she would have had the courtesy to ask me first.”
“The firefighters brought the mailer to me and said, ‘You know, you can’t endorse candidates,’ and I said, ‘What? I know. I don’t even know who she is,” he explained.
Rien also said he doesn’t recall when the photo was taken. Asked if it was during the push-in ceremony for the new fire truck at one of the Brentwood fire stations earlier this year, he said, “We had a push-in event. I do the blessing and the dedication.”
That push-in ceremony was held in June and Mendoza was in attendance for the event. (See related article)
“I don’t even remember taking the photo,” Rien added.
“The bishop sent us two letters telling us clearly we cannot endorse in any political campaigns,” the priest and fire chaplain explained. “It could jeopardize our 501c3 status.”
Rien Asks for Council Censure of Mendoza, Action from Diocese
When reached once more today, Tuesday, Oct. 22, Rien said he still hadn’t heard from Mendoza and that he had sent a letter to the city council asking for them to censure the councilwoman for not taking responsibility for her actions.
“I thought she would have at least apologized to me and for causing us potential challenges,” Rien added who said he would be contacting the vicar asking him to request the Diocese’s Bishop to take further action.
A portion of Jovita Mendoza’s campaign material showing her claim about the fire district merger as an accomplishment.
Says Mendoza’s Fire District Merger Claim False
The mailer from Mendoza’s campaign also claims as one of her accomplishments, “Improved emergency services with the merger of the ECCRFPD and CoCoCo Fire, with no additional taxes placed on residents.”
About the fire district merger claim Rien was emphatic saying, “She had absolutely nothing to do with the merger. I knew who was working to make it happen and happen smoothly. Brian Helmick, Chief Brochard and Diane Burgis were the ones, and Brian Oftedal was the president of the fire board at the time and was working with them.”
“I know who did and didn’t work on it and for her to continue to take credit is just completely dishonest,” the priest stated.
As previously reported, on March 9, 2022, the Contra Costa County Local Area Formation Commission (LAFCo) unanimously approved the annexation of East Contra Costa Fire Protection District (ECCFPD) to the Contra Costa County Fire Protection District (CCCFPD) and the dissolution of ECCFPD. Oftedal was President of the ECCFPD Board of Directors at that time. The two fire districts finalized their merger on July 1, 2022, during a Transfer of Command ceremony.
Oftedal Takes Issue with Mendoza’s Claim
Her opponent, Contra Costa County Fire Advisory Commission Chair and former President of the East Contra Costa Fire Protection District Board, Oftedal responded to Mendoza’s claim and shared a video excerpt from a recent candidates’ forum. He said, “Councilmember Mendoza is claiming some sort of responsibility for fixing ECCFPD and also that she returns all emails (as seen in the video attached).”
In that video Mendoza said, “I always return every single email, every single call, every single Facebook comment or Facebook message or in the Next Door.”
Jovita Mendoza’s 2024 re-election campaign Facebook page showing her official City email address (see yellow outlined box) for voters to contact her. Screenshot taken Oct. 22, 2024.
Questions for Mendoza Go Unanswered
A copy of her mailer containing the photo with Rien and the video shared by Oftedal were sent to Mendoza on Friday afternoon, Oct. 18, 2024, asking her the following questions: “To give you the benefit of the doubt, have you seen and read his email (as sometimes they end up in junk folders if it was the first time Fr. Rien has emailed you)? Have you been out of town on vacation and unable to access your emails?”
She was also asked, “Did you intend the photo to imply Fr. Rien’s endorsement? If not, did you or whomever is helping your campaign think to ask him or those in the other photos for their permission to appear on the mailer? Have you contacted Fr. Rien, today and will you now publicly state that the use of the photo with him was done without his permission and that it does not constitute an endorsement of your campaign?”
“How many copies of the mailer were sent out?” Mendoza was also asked.
She was also informed that Oftedal is challenging the claim in her mailer taking credit for the fire district merger and that no tax increases were incurred. Mendoza was then asked, “What role did you play in the merger before LAFCo approved it in March 2022 and ensuring there were ‘no additional taxes placed on residents’?”
Finally, the councilwoman was asked, “On another matter, why are you using your official, taxpayer-funded City email address for your campaign, as it appears on your re-election Facebook page instead of either a personal or campaign email address?”
As of Tuesday, Oct. 22, Mendoza had not responded.
Oftedal Challenges Mendoza’s Claim of Returning All Calls and Emails, Use of City Email for Campaign, Failure to Sign City Council Code of Conduct
Oftedal shared additional comments about the mailer saying, “Councilmember Mendoza clearly indicated during our recorded Brentwood Candidate Forum that she returns all forms of communication. As of today, my understanding is that Father Robert Rein is still waiting for an email reply, to clear his name with his superiors. As humans, we all make mistakes. If this was a mistake, I can’t understand why a simple apology couldn’t be shared.”
“As an FYI, I did reach out to Father Robert to check on his situation earlier today and he indicated that he is [sic] still not received a reply from my opponent and indicated that he submitted a public comment for tonight‘s City Council meeting,” the first-time council candidate continued.
Informed of Mendoza’s use of her official City email address on her campaign Facebook page (which continued through today) Oftedal replied, “I was not aware that my opponent was using city resources for her political campaign. I find it odd that she would not be aware that officeholders cannot use their taxpayer funded email address for campaign related activities.”
In addition, as of earlier this month, according to a ContraCosta.news report, the councilwoman has refused to sign the Brentwood City Council Code of Conduct which her opponent challenged.
“I find it bizarre that Ms. Mendoza will not sign the current Code of Conduct, yet all of the other sitting council members have signed,” Oftedal stated. “I know I am not the only community member that has concern over her rationale shared at the Brentwood Candidate Forum”.
UPDATE 1: Mendoza Doubles Down, Won’t Apologize
Jovita Mendoza in the Facebook video regarding her campaign mailer in which the photo with Fr. Rien appeared. Screenshot.
Instead of responding by phone or email to the Herald or calling Fr. Rien to apologize, Mendoza posted a video on her campaign Facebook page on Wednesday, Oct. 23, in which she doubled down on her use of the photo with the fire chaplain, claiming she’s known him since she was young, and he was friends with her husband’s parents, while repeatedly referring to him as “Father Bob”. She also admitted she sent her husband, Michael Kleeman, whom she claims is her campaign manager, to speak with the priest in person to “clear the air with him,” she said. That occurred during a funeral Fr. Rien was conducting at St. Ignatius Church in Antioch.
The candidate also said she doesn’t believe the letter to the editor was sent by the fire chaplain. However, it was received from Fr. Rien’s personal email account, and this reporter spoke with him that same day to verify he sent it, as is done with all letters to the editor submitted to the Herald. It was also forwarded to Mendoza with the aforementioned questions. See below:
Fr. Robert Rien emailed Letter to the Editor received by the Herald on Thursday, Oct. 17, 2024. Screenshot.
In addition, in her video Mendoza said, “I called the parish on the 10th as soon as I found out he was upset about the mailer. That was the first thing I did. I spoke to his assistant, she transferred me to his voicemail, I left a message, name, number, information, everything he needed.”
“I also called the bishop’s office,” she continued. “The reason I did that was this was my mailer. No one on here was endorsing me. This is just information about me and what I’ve been doing the last four years. So, I wanted to make sure he was OK. Spoke to his personal assistant, she said she didn’t know what I was talking about. She told me if there was an issue she’d call me back. No one has called me back from the bishop’s office. I have yet to hear from them. So, I’m thinking it might be a non-issue.”
Regarding Rien’s quote that she had absolutely nothing to do with the (district) merger, Mendoza said she worked for it as an activist and a resident but not in her official capacity as a city council member.
She said, “That one is really false. What East Contra Costa County Fire wanted to do is stick us with $450 more per parcel on our property tax bill and I was not OK with that. So, what was going on in those days, I was…advocating…everywhere on social media, everyone I could talk to, don’t, let’s not do this, let’s do this.”
“So, at one point the chief of fire was actually trolling me all over social media,” Mendoza continued. “And I didn’t make it public. I just sent him an email and I said, ‘you need to stop harassing me. I’m not going to change my mind. I’m not going to support a tax no matter how much you want me to. It’s not gonna happen and you need to look at other options like a merger.’ I even offered my help to help them do that. So, when people say we don’t things as residents, oh, no, we do. And we’re not going to let them take away the credit that we deserve for what we do in our city.”
“And yes, I did fight for that merger and once we got Prop X on the ballot, I was out there advocating for it every single day. When they found out we weren’t going to support a tax they had to shift their plans,” she claimed.
About his letter to the editor Mendoza said, “I think someone is strong arming him to do it” and claimed “The fire department is not happy with him” referring to Fr. Rien. She then went on to claim, “He’s getting pressure from a government agency.”
As of Thursday night, Oct. 24, her video had received 25 “Likes” and 13 comments in response.
UPDATE 2: Rien Says No One Calls Him “Father Bob”, Did Work at Schools Mendoza Mentioned but “They Never Were Longtime ‘Family Friends’”
Although Rien said last week, he did not want to deal with the matter further, after an article by the ContraCosta.news about the incident with Jovita Mendoza’s husband during the funeral was published on Tuesday, Oct. 29th, additional questions were posed to the priest.
Asked if anyone else refers to him as “Father Bob”, if Mendoza might have him confused with another priest in the Diocese, and if he recalls being either her or Kleeman’s priest when they were in elementary school Rien responded, “I have been ordained 50 years this year and no one calls me, father, Bob! For at least 47 years of my life as a priest I have been referred to as father, Robert. So, I don’t know how she’s able to call me that because I don’t even think she was born when I was ordained and that was in 1974. I don’t know how old she is but even still, and as far as I know, there is no other priest, with my name in Far East County, or in Antioch. I am just hoping that this will finally put this to rest and all of it will stop. Thank you for your personal support; it is greatly appreciated.
According to MyLife.com, Jovita R. Mendoza of Brentwood, CA is 52. So, she was born in either 1971 or 1972 depending her date of birth.
In her video she also said, “My husband came across a picture with Father Bob and what you all may not know about Father Bob is that Father Bob has history with our family. Father Bob was my preschool priest and elementary school for, I think, a year or so. Then he left St. Leander’s where I went and then he went to Corpus Christi where my husband went and he was my husband’s elementary school priest all through eighth grade, and Father Bob was friends with his mom and dad. They knew each other. So, we have a family history with Father Bob and that’s why we were excited to use the picture.”
Asked if he had worked at St. Leander’s Elementary School and Corpus Christi Elementary where she claims “Father Bob” worked when she and her husband attended those schools, the fire chaplain responded with the correct information about his work history. He said, “I was at Corpus Christi Piedmont as the Vicar from 1977 to 1982 and then went down to St. Leander in San Leandro where I was the Vicar from 1982 to 1987. I had very little to do with the school or the preschool as we were doing six to eight funerals a week as well as taking care of doctors, hospital, Vesper, the restrooms, and the convalescent home patients and I really had very little time for anything else besides the daily and Sunday masses.”
“They never were longtime ‘family friends’, and I certainly never knew that they married one another! I was stunned when I found out that Bill Kleeman’s son, Michael, had married her; I had no idea,” he continued. “My responsibility at both parishes was to the parish and their ministries, but not the schools; perhaps an occasional walk-through, or perhaps presiding for a school mass, but certainly nothing more than that.”
Publisher’s Note: Anyone running for office should obtain the permission of anyone who appears in photos used in their campaign, especially the use of photos of officials. Because it gives the false impression that the person supports and endorses the candidate. It’s a common practice which I’ve applied in my own campaigns and made sure the candidates’ campaigns for whom I’ve managed or consulted on since 1989 also follow.”
The election is November 5th.
Leave a Reply