Antioch man arrested for stealing mail from 22 Brentwood victims

Craig Whiteley, Jr. fled scene with two other suspects; found with keys, drugs, cash, ammo

By Brentwood Police Department

In the early morning hours of December 14, 2025, at approximately 5:38 a.m., Brentwood Police officers responded to a report of suspicious activity near community mailboxes in the 2700 block of Empire Avenue.

A witness reported seeing three male suspects flee on foot after being startled, leaving behind the vehicle they arrived in. When officers arrived, they found the community mailboxes had been compromised and stolen mail belonging to multiple residents was located inside the suspect vehicle, which had been left running.

Officers quickly set up a search of the surrounding area and located 37-year-old Craig Allen Whiteley, Jr. from Antioch who matched the suspect description and appeared to have recently fled on foot. A records check revealed the individual was on felony probation for firearm- and mail theft-related offenses.

During the investigation, officers recovered evidence linking the suspect to the mail theft. A subsequent search led to the discovery of keys used to access mail boxes, narcotics intended for sale and ammunition.

The suspect was arrested and booked into County Jail on charges including probation violation, mail theft, narcotics possession and additional related offenses.

All 22 victims had their stolen mail successfully recovered and returned.

Excellent work by our graveyard officers for their swift response and diligent investigation.

Residents are encouraged to report suspicious activity immediately to help keep our neighborhoods safe.

According to the Brentwood Police website, Whitely is five-feet, 11-inch tall, 160-pound white male.

According to the Contra Costa County Sheriff’s Office, as of Dec. 17, 2025, at 9:11 PM, Whitely was out of custody with no charges filed.

Allen D. Payton contributed to this report.